Is it possible Kubiak truly isn’t well enough to coach an NFL team?

Texans head coach Gary Kubiak, who is (by all accounts) a good man, recently suffered a mini stroke (technically a transient ischemic attack).

He wasn’t able to coach last weekend, but his doctors and the Texans decided he would be fine to coach THIS weekend. Two weeks after a major neurological event (not trying to be a smartass, just stating the facts).

Before this week’s game, I wasn’t so sure Kubiak should be back on the sideline. A Houston Cougar quarterback, after all, had to quit football after he suffered a brain injury early in the season. Texas Longhorn quarterback David Ash may face the same fate. Kubiak didn’t suffer a concussion, but a mini-stroke is not a trivial health/neurological issue.

So, here’s an excerpt from the Houston Chronicle‘s Astros-beat-writer-turned-Texans-beat-writer following today’s debacle:

Case Keenum was surprised. So was Matt Schaub. Reliant Stadium was stunned. Gary Kubiak thought everything about his shocking move made perfect sense.

Schaub, a former starter turned backup, suddenly replaced Keenum, a former third-stringer turned starter, with 2 minutes, 26 seconds left in the third quarter during the Texans’ 28-23 defeat to the Oakland Raiders on Sunday at Reliant Stadium.

As boos crashed down – forcing the Texans to turn to a silent count just so they could run plays – a season that was already surreal, depressing and embarrassing escaped description.

[snip]

Keenum barely knew the move was coming. Schaub was equally caught off guard, only learning about his first series as the team’s starter in more than a month when word came down minutes before his promotion.

“It was a quick turnaround. I think right actually when the defense had a third down and we were about to get a punt, so I only got a few throws before I got to go back out there,” said Schaub, who finished 12-of-25 for 155 yards and a 67.9 rating, leading two field-goal drives but failing to convert a go-ahead touchdown on the Texans’ final possession.

[snip]

Kubiak didn’t intend to make the move when he walked into Reliant on Sunday and didn’t mention the Texans’ horrible third-down conversion rate (2-of-16.) The eighth-year coach only cited two reasons for the change: The Texans wanted to increase their offensive tempo and Schaub, a 10-year veteran, was better equipped to handle in-game call changes that addressed protection issues.

“I knew he could get all that done and I thought it would be very difficult to put Case in that situation,” Kubiak said.

Left guard Wade Smith didn’t know anything about protection issues.

Wide receiver Andre Johnson – who became involved in a heated verbal exchange with Schaub at the end of the defeat – said the Texans’ game plan wasn’t altered when the former starter took over.

“The plays we were running were the stuff we normally run,” Johnson said. “I wouldn’t say it was a big change with anything.”

Again, not trying to be a smartass, but even the players aren’t backing up the coach’s bizarre decisions and reasoning on this one (and this is a player’s coach, so they almost ALWAYS have his back on virtually anything).

Is Kubiak well enough to be trying to coach an NFL team right now?

One Response to “Is it possible Kubiak truly isn’t well enough to coach an NFL team?”

Read below or add a comment...

  1. Jim Bell says:

    ***Is Kubiak well enough to be trying to coach an NFL team right now?***

    The answer is no, but this isn’t the question that’s facing the Texans. I submit it is now time for Bob McNair to face the right question, which is “is Kubiak capable of being a head coach in the NFL?” My answer to that is no he’s not.

    Kubiak has had eight years to fashion a team that can play competitively and he hasn’t done it yet, and GM Rick Smith deserves a large share of the blame for that. With the lone exception of Andre Johnson, the team we all saw yesterday, and saw in seven straight games before it, was created by Kubiak and Smith.

    There are some truly talented and even great individual players, JJ Watt leads that short list, but for reasons that defy explanation, these talented players can’t seem to learn to play as a team and win games.

    I don’t attend Kubiak’s Monday post-mortem news conferences, but here’s the gist of what we can expect him to say. He’ll say they didn’t get it done, made too many defensive mistakes and failures, “and that’s on me. I didn’t do a good enough job of preparing them for this game.” To that let me add the fact he can also take the blame for the failures on offense because he’s the one calling the plays.

    That’s what he says after every loss, and you know what? I’m tired of hearing it. He’s right. It IS on Kubiak. He didn’t didn’t do a good enough job of preparing them, and I’m tired of waiting for him to learn to do the job he was hired to do. How far down do they have to sink before McNair faces the facts and replaces him? Are they playing for draft choices now?

    I don’t think McNair will do a Jerry Jones and fire Kubiak with games still on the schedule, but he should, and send Rick Smith packing too. It could be their only hope of injecting some life into this lifeless team and putting a few W’s on the board.

Leave A Comment...

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>